Army Historian Answers World War II Questions
Credits:
Director: Lisandro Perez-Rey
Director of Photography: Charlie Jordan
Editor: Paul Tael; Richard Trammell
Expert: Dr. Peter Knight
Line Producer: Jamie Rasmussen
Associate Producer: Paul Gulyas; Brandon White
Production Manager: Peter Brunette
Production Coordinator: Rhyan Lark
Casting Producer: Nick Sawyer
Camera Operator: Paola Esquivel-Oliveros
Sound Mixer: Sean Paulsen
Post Production Supervisor: Christian Olguin
Post Production Coordinator: Stella Shortino
Supervising Editor: Eduardo Araujo
Additional Editor: Sam DiVito
Assistant Editor: Justin Symonds
Released on 11/25/2025
PeePeePooPooMan42 asks,
How did the allies in World War II decipher German enigma?
As a former military intelligence officer myself, the story
of breaking the Enigma codes is fascinating to me.
I'm Peter Knight from the US Army
Center of Military History.
Let's answer your questions from the internet.
This is World War II Support.
[upbeat music]
AceofSpades629 asks, What is the best statistic
that puts the scale of World War II into perspective?
One statistic
that really stands out is the death toll,
upwards of 85 million people,
including military and civilians perish.
There were 100 million combatants from 50 nations.
In terms of gross domestic product spending,
the United States spent between 35
and 40% annually, Germany 50%.
Here is a question from Quora.
What is the timeline of World War Two?
Most historians
and scholars agree, the proximate start
of the Second World War is Hitler's invasion
of Poland on September 1st, 1939,
because at that point,
Hitler's invasion causes Great Britain
and France to declare war on Germany
because they have guaranteed the security of Poland.
Our next point will come in 1941
when the Soviet Union is invaded by Hitler.
Russia had initially signed a non-aggression pact
with Hitler, and they agreed to divide Poland
between them when Hitler invaded in September,
however, Hitler turns the tables on Joseph Stalin
and invades the Soviet Union in the summer of 1941.
This brings us to our third turning point,
the Battle of the Atlantic in 1943.
This is a battle for control of the Atlantic Sea lanes
that enable the United States
to send war material across the Atlantic
to the aid of Russia and Britain.
Unless they can secure those sea lanes,
that equipment will be taken out
and the German U-boats run roughshod,
sinking millions of tons of Allied shipping.
Our next point would be the D-Day landings
on June the sixth, 1944, the allies established a beachhead
and a foothold on the continent of Europe
and open up a crucial second front
against Hitler's Nazi forces.
Our next major point are the two atomic bombings
on Hiroshima and Nagasaki on August the sixth
and the ninth 1945, Emperor Hirohito
knows it's only a matter of time
and he gives a radio address.
This is the first time that many
of his subjects in Japan have ever heard his voice,
and he asks them to endure the unendurable
and submit to the unconditional surrender
to the allied powers, which brings us to our final point.
September 2nd, 1945, the Japanese sign the instrument
of surrender aboard the USS Missouri in Tokyo Bay
and World War II is brought to an end.
HHT_Lucas asks,
Y'all ever think about how the Nazis were on meth
like all the time?
Nazi soldiers did indeed
get methamphetamines distributed to them.
The idea was that these very powerful drugs
would allow them to stay awake for longer periods of time,
would enhance their mental alertness,
their aggressiveness, essentially enable them
to succeed and win in combat.
But there were some significant side effects,
extreme exhaustion and hallucinations.
That being said, it wasn't just the troops
that were getting drugs.
Hitler received all kinds of opioid injections, oxycodone,
cocaine that were used to help him cope
and get through his day.
On the allied side, GIs and and other allied troops
got what were called Go pills,
Benzedrine, which was an amphetamine, not a methamphetamine.
So these are less powerful
and less potent than the pills the Germans were taking,
and most of the time, Benzedrine was used by allied pilots
that were on these very long bombing run missions,
just to stay awake.
Nobodygrotesque asks,
What are some World War II movies
that are the most historically accurate
that one can learn from?
the Steven Spielberg film Saving Private Ryan
its opening sequence
of the troop landings on Omaha Beach on D-Day
are some of the most realistic depictions I've ever seen,
and they're based largely on soldier accounts.
There's a moment where you'll see soldiers disembarking
from the landing craft and they'll immediately
be submerged in the water.
That's very true to life
because as the landing craft approached the beaches,
some of the parts of the beach
had received some early naval gunfire
and there were craters
and they're stepping off into water
that is over their heads.
So some of these soldiers
who are immediately immersed in the water
and sinking like a stone, they're panicking
and they're getting shot at it the same time,
and some of these unfortunate soldiers
will drown in the process.
Another movie is The Longest Day based on the book
by Cornelius Ryan that shows a lot of the D-Day activities.
For example, the use of dummy paratroopers,
these little straw men that they dressed up
to look like soldiers
and they'd throw them out of the aircraft
to confuse the German forces
as to where the airborne divisions were going to land.
The German term for the dummy was gummipoopen,
and you hear them talking about this over the radio
and they're just ranting about it.
[speaking in foreign language]
It's somewhat humorous in that context.
Kyle Lindsey has a question Ever heard
of the Ghost Army in World War II?
It's one of those wild true tales
that sounds like a Hollywood script, but actually happened.
The name of the unit
is the 23rd Headquarters Special Troops Unit.
This unit's mission is to create the illusion
of military forces in different places
through the use of inflatable tanks,
inflatable troop carrying ships,
fake weaponry, fake radio transmission traffic,
all for the purpose of deceiving
the Axis powers into thinking
that certain troop formations might be larger
than they actually were,
or in the case of the preparation
for Operation Overlord, D-Day,
creating an entire fictional first US army group
allegedly led by General George S. Patton
that would make a landing at the Pas de Calais
as opposed to Normandy
and selling the Germans on that fake plan.
AnniElocin writes, I still don't understand.
Why would Japan bomb Pearl Harbor?
One of the biggest reasons why Japan
decides that they have to attack the US Pacific fleet
is because of an oil embargo
President Franklin Roosevelt imposed upon Japan.
Pearl Harbor is located on the island of Oahu.
Admiral Isoroku Yamamoto,
chief of the Imperial Japanese Navy
believes that they must strike
and cripple the US Pacific fleet
in order to allow Japan the freedom
to embark on their military campaigns
to conquer the Dutch East Indies
and British Malaya over here
that contain the natural resources, oil
and rubber that the Japanese absolutely need
to sustain their war machine and their industrial economy.
If we look at where Japan is, the Philippine Islands
is between the Japanese home islands
and those desired targets.
The United States controls the Philippine Islands
and they will be attacked within nine hours
after the attack on Pearl Harbor.
The Japanese will attack Pearl Harbor
on Sunday morning, December 7th, 1941.
They will succeed in crippling several of the battleships,
especially the USS Arizona
that will carry over 2000 soldiers to their death,
and it does do a lot to set back the US Pacific fleet,
but it does not succeed in destroying it.
Japan missed our oil and fuel refineries
and our big dry dock facilities that will enable us
to continue to fuel and supply our fleet and repair it
and recover from the loss.
@MatchlessMine asks,
When did Hitler declare war on the US?
Adolf Hitler declares war on the United States
on December 11th, 1941, a mere four days
after the Japanese attack Pearl Harbor.
Sipwell asks How effective were German U-boats
in World War II?
From the start in 1939, easily through most of 1942,
German U-boats successfully sank over six million tons
of allied shipping.
You're sinking allied shipping
faster than the allies can build the ships.
Some of those sinkings occur within sight
of the US coastline.
The biggest single factor
that turns the tables on the German U-boats
is the cracking of the German enigma codes.
The cracking of the enigma codes allows the allies
better success in locating the U-boats and destroying them.
This is huge because with the German U-boat threat negated,
this enables the allied forces to move enough men
and material, planes, vehicles, weapons over to England
to be able to stage for the invasion of Western Europe.
PeePeePooPooMan42 asks,
How did the allies in World War II decipher German enigma
if there were millions of possibilities for letters
and it was being changed every day?
I absolutely love this question.
As a former military intelligence officer myself,
the story of breaking the enigma codes
is fascinating to me.
The allies are able to crack the German enigma
due to a number of different factors.
Polish cryptanalysts
and mathematicians were able
to reconstruct the German enigma machine
and smuggle a version of it out of Poland
just as the Germans were invading
in September, 1939, that copy of Enigma
was given to the British.
The British then take it
and put it in the hands of their cryptanalysts
working out of Bletchley Park
and those cryptanalysts partner
with American mathematicians and cryptanalysts
and one in particular by the name of Alan Turing.
He is able to invent an electro mechanical machine
that is able to compute the different combinations
that the enigma machine can generate
and then they're able to crack the enigma codes
because of the human frailties of the system.
Those who would be creating enigma traffic
would use certain phrases the same way each day
and looking for those same phrases or messages
or plain text, which we refer to as cribs,
helped the code breakers be able to determine
what the enigma machine settings would be.
Most experts will estimate the cracking
of enigma alone shorten the war
anywhere between two and four years.
Here's a question from World War II Subreddit.
How far back does the chain of events go
to lead to World War II?
World War II has its roots in the First World War
and the Treaty of Versailles,
Germany is forced to pay crippling reparations
to demilitarize and accept full responsibility
for the First World War.
This, combined with the Great Depression
absolutely cripples the German economy
and the German people are looking
for a hope, a way out of this.
Adolf Hitler provides that
by promising to remilitarize Germany,
to revive the German economy
and its war machine for the purposes
of territorial expansion.
In the meantime,
Japan embarks upon imperial expansion,
invading China in 1931.
These are the chain of events that set things in motion.
A question from the Ask Historian Subreddit is,
Were there any nations totally unaffected by World War II?
The short answer to that question is no.
Although there are 14 nations
that maintained neutrality status
throughout the entirety of the Second World War.
Among those 14 were nations like Sweden, Switzerland,
Yemen, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Ireland,
small little states like Lichtenstein and the Vatican City,
and they would help either side as it suited their purposes.
This map, although it's in Russian,
certainly shows you the battle lines
and movements of large troop formations across the globe
over the course of the Second World War.
And as you can see, the war leaves basically
no part of the planet unscathed.
Here you can see a lot of the action in Europe.
You look in the Pacific,
it's a much more spread out, wide area,
different island chains,
but then India of course is part of the British empire,
and so Britain is going to fight to protect that
and the China Burma India area is referred to
as a China Burma India theater
where the American Commander Vinegar Joe Stilwell
works to advance allied interests
and defeat Japanese forces in this area.
So as you can see,
between the European Theater of Operations
and the Pacific Theater of Operations,
this is truly a global conflict.
RippinDankBonks wants to know What was the point
of the invasion of Normandy from a tactical standpoint?
The invasion of Normandy
from a tactical standpoint probably doesn't make
a lot of sense to the average viewer
when you have to fight up over the beach
against elevated German positions in concrete pill boxes,
it seems like an impossible task,
but you have to remember,
you can't just airdrop armored divisions
from planes onto the ground in Europe,
there are German armored forces
already on the continent.
They have to create a beachhead.
The Normandy beachhead is the ideal place for the allies
to strike because it is the weakest point
of the Atlantic wall defenses
and it has the best beach front area
to make their amphibious assault
onto the continent of Europe.
This picture is taken just after D-Day.
Now they're gonna begin
to pump their logistics up onto the European continent.
The balloons that you see are designed
to be an impediment to enemy aircraft.
They have cables there
that would entangle the aircraft if they were to try
to fly a bombing run or a strafing run along the beach.
DougSaysHowdy03 asks,
What is your favorite war tactic that was used
or developed in World War II?
One of my favorites is hedgerow busting,
as allied forces were bogged down in the hedgerow country
in Normandy, the hedgerows are these large
earthen embankments
that mark the property boundaries of farmers' fields.
The Germans used these earthen berms as defensive lines
that they would hide behind
and then place their crew serve weapons
and wreak havoc on any allied troops
that were coming across the fields.
The allies had to find a way
to quickly get across the hedgerow country.
They take some of these steel beams that were used
to make the hedgehogs, the tetrahedron shaped obstacles
that you see on the landing beaches on D-Day,
they cut some of those with acetylene torches
and welded them to the front of their Sherman tanks,
and then they used that protrusion
to bust through the earthern berm of the hedgerow,
and this was highly effective so they could spearhead
with the tanks and then the infantry
could follow on through,
and that was what they used to help bust out
of the hedgerow country
where they would launch Operation Cobra
and Patton's third army would start
to sweep across the European continent.
Ironside asks, Reading up on World War II
for the first time, the axis powers versus the allies ey,
who named them, a damn fan fiction writer.
The name Axis Powers is actually coined
by Italian dictator Benito Mussolini, who referred
to his relationship to Nazi Germany
as forming an axis around which the rest
of the European nations would rally around.
The term allies is actually a holdover from World War I
because that is how the triple ante powers Russia,
Great Britain, France referred to themselves.
The allies are united out of necessity
to keep one another in the war to be able
to sustain their ability to wage the war.
For the axis powers,
their shared interest is territorial expansion,
but each of them are not necessarily
so invested in helping one another
unless it's really necessary.
You're not gonna find German troops fighting in the Pacific,
for example, and the level of cooperation
of the political leadership is much greater
on the allied side than you will find on the axis side.
Mussolini often becomes more of a puppet
of Hitler than anything else.
NFTCryptoGod asks, What is the Blitzkrieg?
Blitzkrieg is a term that western journalists like to apply
to the German approach to offensive operations.
The better term is or maneuver warfare,
and the Germans use this tactic which involves speed
and the combination of infantry,
artillery, armor and close air support
to attack the enemy in their weakest positions,
to allow them to bypass enemy strong points
and then surround the enemy and destroy them.
German forces could cover hundreds of miles
of territory in a matter of a few hours.
Opponents could not respond with a coherent defense in time.
in a matter of weeks, they will overrun France
and force the British forces to evacuate
from the continent of Europe through Dunkirk.
DeniseViolaplay asks, Wow,
I never knew about the World War II Bat Bomb project.
In the New Mexico desert
where the Manhattan Project is underway at Los Alamos
trying to develop the atomic bomb,
there was also the idea
that we could use bats to deliver incendiary devices
against Japanese villages whose buildings
were made largely of paper and wood.
You would freeze the bats
and then place the incendiary napalm containing devices
to the chest of the bats
and place them in canisters
that could then be parachuted down onto enemy soil.
And then the bats,
once they were released from their canisters,
would take refuge in the various Japanese building
structures and then the incendiary device would go off.
They tested this in New Mexico
and they ended up burning down other structures
rather unintentionally, and I think
they thought better the idea
because once you release the bats,
you can't get them to stop,
after that it's really out of your hands.
Tripster asks, Why was Iwo Jima
so important to the war effort?
It's just a naked eight mile square rock in the Pacific.
Iwo Jima is certainly more significant than that.
In 1945,
the allied forces have captured the Mariana Islands.
Those islands will allow B29 long range bombers
to range the Japanese home islands.
Iwo Jima lies halfway between the Mariana Islands
and the Japanese home islands,
and the Japanese had an early warning radar system
deployed on Iwo Jima that needed to be knocked out
to enable those bombing runs from the Mariani
to be successful, one of the most famous pictures
in all of history is an associated press photo
that captures US Marines raising the flag
atop Mount Suribachi
the highest elevation on the island of Iwo Jima.
What's interesting about this
is this is the second flag raising.
There was an earlier flag raising,
but then they had to continue fighting
against Japanese that were still resisting
and still, the island of Iwo Jima was not completely secured
until a couple of weeks later
after five weeks of brutal fighting.
SouthsideTilly asks,
Please tell me about the night witches.
The Night Witches were the 588 night bombing regiment
of the Soviet Red Air Force.
This was an all female unit
and does as many as 23,000 missions
and they used these little wooden biplanes.
The speeds of these planes were so slow.
German fighter planes were too fast to even try
to maneuver against these more primitive planes
and these planes would basically throttle down
their engines when they were about to drop their ordinance
and when they did so, they made this whooshing sound
and that's what made the Germans
name these all female pilot squadron.
[speaking in foreign language]
Or Knight Witches.
Their leader was one of the first, actually the first
to receive a state funeral,
having earned the status of hero of the Soviet Union,
her plane crashed in the Battle of Stalingrad.
Here's a question from the Explain Like I'm Five Subreddit,
Why is it Germany, Italy
and Japan allied despite all believing themselves
to be the superior races?
The real reason why these countries ally together
is shared interest in territorial expansion.
For Germany, its Hitler's concept of, living space
for the German peoples
and trying to unite those parts of Europe
that are predominantly German.
For Italy, it's expanding into Africa,
namely Ethiopia, for Japan,
the invasion of China in 1931
and expanding in through Manchuria.
With regard to their superiority of their respective races,
I think they all held that to themselves
and perhaps that was a bit of division between them
as well because they're never as close of an alliance
as the allies will be.
Our next question is from Quora.
Before GPS, how did soldiers in combat
accurately know their location
on the battlefield when they called in close air support?
For soldiers to understand their location
and a target's location, they have to use
the good old fashioned map
and magnetic lensatic compass, I have one here.
This is standard US GI issued magnetic compass.
Soldiers would have to take a known point
on the terrain, shoot an azimuth to it,
and then do the same with some other points
and then basically triangulate their positions
and confirm their position on the ground.
By the way, just an interesting side note
as we're talking about things like the compass
that are a part of a standard GI's equipment kit,
the American GIs would often wear identification bracelets.
They didn't have dog tags necessarily at that time.
This particular soldier, Raymond Toinbee,
served in the 36th Infantry Division in Italy.
Okay, next question.
Innergameofdenthemen asks,
What did Churchill actually do in World War II?
Sir Winston Churchill is the prime minister of Great Britain
and his relationship with US President
Franklin Roosevelt is absolutely essential
to cementing allied war strategy
to allow the allies to prevail.
He was a hard drinker and incessant smoker.
He actually had a pension for liking to walk
around naked in his household
and he even did so at the White House
when he was visiting there one time.
His favorite outlet was painting.
He actually had his own painting studio
at his home in Chartwell.
Winston Churchill is an inspiration to the British people.
His people were able to look to him
and he provided them a beacon of hope
on which to focus.
In late 1940 and 41,
as the Germans are bombing London, Churchill is a steady,
calm voice to the British people, telling them
that we will continue to resist
and that we will never surrender to Nazi tyranny.
Here's another one from the Ask Historian Subreddit,
In the famous scene from the movie Dar Untergang,
and here they're actually referring to the movie Downfall.
Hitler orders all of his generals
to leave the room except Keitel, Jodl, Krebs and Burgdorf.
Who were they
and why were they different or more important?
So the movie Downfall depicts the final days
for Adolf Hitler as he's hunkered down in the Führer Bunker
in Berlin as the Soviet red army closes in
on the German capital
and Hitler is forced to face the reality
that his last ditch efforts
to defend the German capital are amounting to nothing.
He dismisses most of the officers in the room
and sticks only with his very close inner circle.
Wilhelm Keitel, the chief of staff
of the German high command.
Alfred Jodl is the chief operations officer
of the German.
Hans Krebs is the chief of staff
for the German high headquarters
and Burgdorf is Hitler's Agitant general.
This is his inner circle,
along with his propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels,
and they're the ones that remain in the room
and he goes into this long tirade, berating his generals,
calling them cowards, but it's really just a raging rant
after which he admits that the war is lost.
That fateful meeting takes place on the 22nd of April, 1945
as the Red Army is closing in on Berlin
and the deterioration is just accelerating.
Hitler is thinking in his own mind that he's a dead man
and now he's trying to figure out, well, if I'm gonna die,
I think I wanna die on my own terms.
He looks at what happens to Benito Mussolini
who is hung and his body left on display
in Milan on April 28th, 1945,
to be humiliated
and desecrated by Italian partisans in his country.
He decides that it's better for him
to take his own life, which he does.
He takes a pistol and shoots himself in the head.
He leaves instructions to take his body and burn it.
However, when the Soviets take Berlin,
they go into the Führer bunker,
they actually find some dental remains
and they're able to positively identify Hitler
from his dental records and confirm that he's dead,
though they don't make that fact known
to the rest of the world.
Here's another one.
What do you think was the turning point
of World War II?
One of the big turning points is Hitler's decision
to invade the Soviet Union.
He's banking on his ability having overrun Western Europe,
that he can conquer the Soviet Union
before the British, French
and the Americans amass a force against him.
The turning point comes at the battle of Stalingrad.
The entire German sixth army is surrounded in Stalingrad
and forced to surrender.
220,000 German troops,
91,000 will survive to surrender to Soviet forces.
At that point, Germany's momentum
on the eastern front is done.
They will now go on the defensive
and will remain on the defensive
for the duration of the war.
Nealbrownfan69 asks
and I quote, US education is dog [beep].
Why we never talk
about how we hit North Africa first in World War II?
This is a matter of strategy, in 1942,
the Americans are all for going immediately
for the cross channel invasion into Northern Europe.
In order to facilitate a cross channel invasion
into Northern Europe,
you have to have enough water transport
to put your troops and all of your material on the ground.
They did not have enough landing craft
to be able to accomplish that feat.
What they decided was the American troops
have to commit somewhere
so that they can get some combat experience on the ground
'cause they haven't really fought since World War I.
That is why we do the torch landings in 1942
to land in North Africa
and trap Rommel's army
between the British eighth Army under Montgomery
coming out of Egypt and the American forces
coming in through Morocco and Algiers.
Mike Miller wants to know, Patton was a great general,
but do you think he would be good
as the top general of an army?
He was a little crazy laugh out loud,
which is what made him interesting.
George S. Patton was certainly one
of the most talented generals that the Americans had.
He was a fighting general.
Taylor made to command an armored division,
an armored corps, and an army in combat,
and he does all of those things in World War II.
He was not the diplomat that Dwight Eisenhower was.
I don't know that he would've been a great supreme commander
in terms of working with the allied partners.
Patton was very outspoken, very passionate
and very pragmatic,
and also a bit of a prima donna
when it came to ensuring the success
of his own campaigns
and getting his name in the headlines a bit.
He had a bit of an ego there,
but he had a dogged determination
in combat, his exploits with the third US army
during the Battle of the Bulge where he comes
to the liberation of Bastogne,
covering many miles in just under 72 hours
and attacking the Germans, rescuing the 101st
that was encircled there.
It's one of the most tremendous feats
of armed combat in American and world history.
Mad_Season_1994 asks,
How much did the German population know
about the concentration camps during World War II?
How much did the Americans and other allies know?
German knowledge of the concentration camps varies
depending on their proximity to the camps
and their involvement in the operations of the camps.
While folks who lived in
or near the concentration camps probably knew of them
and had some idea of what was going on in there,
whether or not they were aware of the methods
of mass murder is up for debate.
When did senior leaders like President Franklin Roosevelt
find out about the camps?
They have knowledge of the camps as early as 1942
and then they have knowledge of the Zyklon B gas chambers
and the extermination method there in 1944.
Senior leaders like Eisenhower
and Patton actually make it a point
to take the local German citizenry
and make them walk through the camps,
such that Germany can never deny
what was taking place there.
The evidence of the Holocaust
and the treatment of the Jewish prisoners is irrefutable.
There are photographs, there is documented film footage
of liberating these camps,
seeing the emaciated bodies of the deceased
and the emaciated bodies of those still living
and seeing some of these prisoners
in striped pajama type outfits.
You just look at them
and you can see that they have been starving.
So for the American soldiers
that are rolling up on these camps
and liberating them, the shock effect is palpable.
The allied leadership is very adamant
that this be recorded such that future generations
could never dispute the fact.
Petite-Acorn asks,
Why was Eisenhower chosen
over other more experienced generals
as Supreme Allied Commander in Europe?
Dwight David Eisenhower never commanded
a large combat formation.
People wonder, well, why would we choose this man
as opposed to others who are much more seasoned,
have more battlefield experience
or leading larger size units?
Dwight Eisenhower was selected for this position
by General George C. Marshall,
the US Army's chief of staff.
In the years just prior to the outbreak of war
for the United States, Eisenhower is instrumental
in helping to craft the war plans
and war strategy of the United States
in the event that it were to enter the war,
he had the personality
and the diplomatic skills to be able to work
with both politicians
and his fellow general officers of the Allied Coalition.
He began as the commander
of American forces in the European Theater of Operations.
He's appointed such in 1942,
just ahead of Operation Torch, the landings in North Africa.
A year later, he's named the Supreme commander
of the Allied Expeditionary Force
that will make the cross channel invasion into Europe.
A question from Quora.
Was America's mainland bombed or attacked in World War II?
The answer is yes.
There was a Japanese sub
that lobbed some shells against a fort in Oregon
and against an oil field in Santa Barbara, California
and there were some 900 fuku 90 balloons
that Japan launched armed with incendiary explosive devices
that were meant to explode on North American US soil.
About 100 of those actually made it to US soil.
I believe that there were six Americans
and there were some women and children in that six
that were killed in the vicinity of Bly, Oregon
as a result of those balloons.
But that was the extent of the damage.
JohnBlackburn75 asked,
Did the Adam bomb really force surrender
of Japan or would it have happened anyway?
How many lives, if any, did the bomb save
on the US side and the Japanese side?
You have to remember
that the Japanese home islands had been firebombed
in the months preceding the two atomic bombs,
and still Japan had not yet surrendered.
The firebombing campaign
and especially the Tokyo firebombing alone
killed over 100,000 Japanese
'cause it created such a firestorm
that sucked up all the ambient oxygen and boiled the rivers.
It just absolutely obliterated everything.
The death toll and the destruction toll
exceeded even the two atomic bombs,
but still, Japanese resolve held firm.
And so I think it was the shock effect
of the atomic bombs being such a terrible
and powerful weapon, plus the knowledge
that the Soviet Union was going to enter the war now,
that's what's gonna break their back.
The planned invasion
of the Japanese home islands
was referred to as Operation Downfall.
Estimated casualties
for the allies were over one million, estimated casualties
for the Japanese population would be over 10 million.
And so it made the decision
for Harry Truman very pragmatic
in that he authorized the dropping of both atomic bombs
to avoid the horrific casualties that would come
with an invasion of the Japanese home islands.
So those are all the questions for today,
and they were good ones.
Thanks for watching World War II Support.
[upbeat music]
Starring: Peter Knight
Gordon Ramsay Answers Cooking Questions From Twitter
Ken Jeong Answers Medical Questions From Twitter
Bill Nye Answers Science Questions From Twitter
Blizzard's Jeff Kaplan Answers Overwatch Questions From Twitter
Nick Offerman Answers Woodworking Questions From Twitter
Bungie's Luke Smith Answers Destiny Questions From Twitter
Jackie Chan & Olivia Munn Answer Martial Arts Questions From Twitter
Scott Kelly Answers Astronaut Questions From Twitter
LaVar Ball Answers Basketball Questions From Twitter
Dillon Francis Answers DJ Questions From Twitter
Tony Hawk Answers Skateboarding Questions From Twitter
Jerry Rice Answers Football Questions From Twitter
Garry Kasparov Answers Chess Questions From Twitter
U.S. Olympic and Paralympic Athletes Answer Olympics Questions From Twitter
Neuroscientist Anil Seth Answers Neuroscience Questions From Twitter
Blizzard's Ben Brode Answers Hearthstone Questions From Twitter
John Cena Answers Wrestling Questions From Twitter
The Slow Mo Guys Answer Slow Motion Questions From Twitter
Bill Nye Answers Even More Science Questions From Twitter
James Cameron Answers Sci-Fi Questions From Twitter
Best of Tech Support: Bill Nye, Neil DeGrasse Tyson and More Answer Science Questions from Twitter
Riot Games' Greg Street Answers League of Legends Questions from Twitter
Riot Games' Greg Street Answers Even More League of Legends Questions from Twitter
PlayerUnknown Answers PUBG Questions From Twitter
Liza Koshy, Markiplier, Rhett & Link, and Hannah Hart Answer YouTube Creator Questions From Twitter
NCT 127 Answer K-Pop Questions From Twitter
Neil deGrasse Tyson Answers Science Questions From Twitter
Ken Jeong Answers More Medical Questions From Twitter
Bon Appétit's Brad & Claire Answer Cooking Questions From Twitter
Bang Bang Answers Tattoo Questions From Twitter
Ed Boon Answers Mortal Kombat 11 Questions From Twitter
Nick Jonas and Kelly Clarkson Answer Singing Questions from Twitter
Penn Jillette Answers Magic Questions From Twitter
The Russo Brothers Answer Avengers: Endgame Questions From Twitter
Alex Honnold Answers Climbing Questions From Twitter
Sloane Stephens Answers Tennis Questions From Twitter
Bill Nye Answers Science Questions From Twitter - Part 3
Astronaut Nicole Stott Answers Space Questions From Twitter
Mark Cuban Answers Mogul Questions From Twitter
Ubisoft's Alexander Karpazis Answers Rainbow Six Siege Questions From Twitter
Marathon Champion Answers Running Questions From Twitter
Ninja Answers Fortnite Questions From Twitter
Cybersecurity Expert Answers Hacking Questions From Twitter
Bon Appétit's Brad & Chris Answer Thanksgiving Questions From Twitter
SuperM Answers K-Pop Questions From Twitter
The Best of Tech Support: Ken Jeong, Bill Nye, Nicole Stott and More
Twitter's Jack Dorsey Answers Twitter Questions From Twitter
Jodie Whittaker Answers Doctor Who Questions From Twitter
Astronomer Jill Tarter Answers Alien Questions From Twitter
Tattoo Artist Bang Bang Answers More Tattoo Questions From Twitter
Respawn Answers Apex Legends Questions From Twitter
Michael Strahan Answers Super Bowl Questions From Twitter
Dr. Martin Blaser Answers Coronavirus Questions From Twitter
Scott Adkins Answers Martial Arts Training Questions From Twitter
Psychiatrist Daniel Amen Answers Brain Questions From Twitter
The Hamilton Cast Answers Hamilton Questions From Twitter
Travis & Lyn-Z Pastrana Answer Stunt Questions From Twitter
Mayim Bialik Answers Neuroscience Questions From Twitter
Zach King Answers TikTok Questions From Twitter
Riot Games Answers League of Legends Questions from Twitter
Aaron Sorkin Answers Screenwriting Questions From Twitter
Survivorman Les Stroud Answers Survival Questions From Twitter
Joe Manganiello Answers Dungeons & Dragons Questions From Twitter
"Star Wars Explained" Answers Star Wars Questions From Twitter
Wizards of the Coast Answer Magic: The Gathering Questions From Twitter
"Star Wars Explained" Answers More Star Wars Questions From Twitter
VFX Artist Answers Movie & TV VFX Questions From Twitter
CrossFit Coach Answers CrossFit Questions From Twitter
Yo-Yo Ma Answers Cello Questions From Twitter
Mortician Answers Cadaver Questions From Twitter
Babish Answers Cooking Questions From Twitter
Jacob Collier Answers Music Theory Questions From Twitter
The Lord of the Rings Expert Answers More Tolkien Questions From Twitter
Wolfgang Puck Answers Restaurant Questions From Twitter
Fast & Furious Car Expert Answers Car Questions From Twitter
Former FBI Agent Answers Body Language Questions From Twitter
Olympian Dominique Dawes Answers Gymnastics Questions From Twitter
Allyson Felix Answers Track Questions From Twitter
Dr. Michio Kaku Answers Physics Questions From Twitter
Former NASA Astronaut Answers Space Questions From Twitter
Surgeon Answers Surgery Questions From Twitter
Beekeeper Answers Bee Questions From Twitter
Michael Pollan Answers Psychedelics Questions From Twitter
Ultramarathoner Answers Questions From Twitter
Bug Expert Answers Insect Questions From Twitter
Former Cult Member Answers Cult Questions From Twitter
Mortician Answers MORE Dead Body Questions From Twitter
Toxicologist Answers Poison Questions From Twitter
Brewmaster Answers Beer Questions From Twitter
Biologist Answers Biology Questions From Twitter
James Dyson Answers Design Questions From Twitter
Dermatologist Answers Skin Questions From Twitter
Dwyane Wade Answers Basketball Questions From Twitter
Baker Answers Baking Questions from Twitter
Astrophysicist Answers Questions From Twitter
Age Expert Answers Aging Questions From Twitter
Fertility Expert Answers Questions From Twitter
Biological Anthropologist Answers Love Questions From Twitter
Mathematician Answers Math Questions From Twitter
Statistician Answers Stats Questions From Twitter
Sleep Expert Answers Questions From Twitter
Botanist Answers Plant Questions From Twitter
Ornithologist Answers Bird Questions From Twitter
Alex Honnold Answers MORE Rock Climbing Questions From Twitter
Former FBI Agent Answers MORE Body Language Questions From Twitter
Waste Expert Answers Garbage Questions From Twitter
Garbage Boss Answers Trash Questions From Twitter
J. Kenji López-Alt Answers Cooking Questions From Twitter
Veterinarian Answers Pet Questions From Twitter
Doctor Answers Gut Questions From Twitter
Chemist Answers Chemistry Questions From Twitter
Taste Expert Answers Questions From Twitter
Paleontologist Answers Dinosaur Questions From Twitter
Biologist Answers More Biology Questions From Twitter
Biologist Answers Even More Biology Questions From Twitter
ER Doctor Answers Injury Questions From Twitter
Toxicologist Answers More Poison Questions From Twitter
Energy Expert Answers Energy Questions From Twitter
BBQ Pitmaster Answers BBQ Questions From Twitter
Neil Gaiman Answers Mythology Questions From Twitter
Sushi Chef Answers Sushi Questions From Twitter
The Lord of the Rings Expert Answers Tolkien Questions From Twitter
Audiologist Answers Hearing Questions From Twitter
Marine Biologist Answers Shark Questions From Twitter
Bill Nye Answers Science Questions From Twitter - Part 4
John McEnroe Answers Tennis Questions From Twitter
Malcolm Gladwell Answers Research Questions From Twitter
Financial Advisor Answers Money Questions From Twitter
Stanford Computer Scientist Answers Coding Questions From Twitter
Wildlife Vet Answers Wild Animal Questions From Twitter
Climate Scientist Answers Earth Questions From Twitter
Medical Doctor Answers Hormone Questions From Twitter
James Hoffmann Answers Coffee Questions From Twitter
Video Game Director Answers Questions From Twitter
Robotics Professor Answers Robot Questions From Twitter
Scam Fighters Answer Scam Questions From Twitter
Forensics Expert Answers Crime Scene Questions From Twitter
Chess Pro Answers Questions From Twitter
Former FBI Agent Answers Body Language Questions From Twitter...Once Again
Memory Champion Answers Questions From Twitter
Neuroscientist Answers Illusion Questions From Twitter
Immunologist Answers Immune System Questions From Twitter
Rocket Scientists Answer Questions From Twitter
How Vinyl Records Are Made (with Third Man Records)
Neurosurgeon Answers Brain Surgery Questions From Twitter
Therapist Answers Relationship Questions From Twitter
Polyphia's Tim Henson Answers Guitar Questions From Twitter
Structural Engineer Answers City Questions From Twitter
Harvard Professor Answers Happiness Questions From Twitter
A.I. Expert Answers A.I. Questions From Twitter
Pizza Chef Answers Pizza Questions From Twitter
Former CIA Chief of Disguise Answers Spy Questions From Twitter
Astrophysicist Answers Space Questions From Twitter
Cannabis Scientist Answers Questions From Twitter
Sommelier Answers Wine Questions From Twitter
Mycologist Answers Mushroom Questions From Twitter
Genndy Tartakovsky Answers Animation Questions From Twitter
Pro Card Counter Answers Casino Questions From Twitter
Doctor Answers Lung Questions From Twitter
Paul Hollywood & Prue Leith Answer Baking Questions From Twitter
Geneticist Answers Genetics Questions From Twitter
Sneaker Expert Jeff Staple Answers Sneaker Questions From Twitter
'The Points Guy' Brian Kelly Answers Travel Questions From Twitter
Master Chef Answers Indian Food & Curry Questions From Twitter
Archaeologist Answers Archaeology Questions From Twitter
LegalEagle's Devin Stone Answers Law Questions From Twitter
Todd McFarlane Answers Comics Questions From Twitter
Reptile Expert Answers Reptile Questions From Twitter
Mortician Answers Burial Questions From Twitter
Eye Doctor Answers Eye Questions From Twitter
Computer Scientist Answers Computer Questions From Twitter
Neurologist Answers Nerve Questions From Twitter
Hacker Answers Penetration Test Questions From Twitter
Nutritionist Answers Nutrition Questions From Twitter
Experts Predict the Future of Technology, AI & Humanity
Doctor Answers Blood Questions From Twitter
Sports Statistician Answers Sports Math Questions From Twitter
Shark Tank's Mark Cuban Answers Business Questions From Twitter
Marvel’s Spider-Man 2 Director Answers Video Game Questions From Twitter
Criminologist Answers True Crime Questions From Twitter
Physicist Answers Physics Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Chess Pro Answers More Questions From Twitter
The Police's Stewart Copeland Answers Drumming Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Ancient Rome Expert Answers Roman Empire Questions From Twitter
Mathematician Answers Geometry Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Toy Expert Answers Toy Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Pepper X Creator Ed Currie Answers Pepper Questions From Twitter
Mineralogist Answers Gemstone Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Jacob Collier Answers Instrument & Music Theory Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Mechanical Engineer Answers Car Questions From Twitter
Dermatologist Answers More Skin Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Egyptologist Answers Ancient Egypt Questions From Twitter
Cardiologist Answers Heart Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Marine Biologist Answers Fish Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Real Estate Expert Answers US Housing Crisis Questions | Tech Support
Paleoanthropologist Answers Caveman Questions From Twitter | Tech Support | WIRED
Zack Snyder Answers Filmmaking Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Survivalist Answers Survival Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Celebrity Trainer Answers Workout Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Primatologist Answers Ape Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Psychiatrist Answers Mental Health Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Maya Expert Answers Maya Civilization Questions From Twitter | Tech Support
Biomedical Scientist Answers Pseudoscience Questions From Twitter
Violinist Answers Violin Questions From Twitter
Lando Norris & Oscar Piastri Answer Formula 1 Questions From Twitter
Medievalist Professor Answers Medieval Questions From Twitter
Stock Trader Answers Stock Market Questions From Twitter
Pyrotechnician Answers Fireworks Questions From Twitter
Storm Chaser Answers Severe Weather Questions From Twitter
Professor Answers Ancient Greece Questions From Twitter
AI Expert Answers Prompt Engineering Questions From Twitter
Etiquette Expert Answers Etiquette Questions From Twitter
'Pod Save America' Hosts Answer Democracy Questions From Twitter
Roller Coaster Engineer Answers Roller Coaster Questions From Twitter
Urban Designer Answers City Planning Questions From Twitter
Joey Chestnut Answers Competitive Eating Questions From Twitter
Aerospace Engineer Answers Airplane Questions From Twitter
Microbiologist Answers Microbiology Questions From Twitter
Viking Age Expert Answers Viking Questions From Twitter
Volcanologist Answers Volcano Questions From Twitter
Private Investigator Answers PI Questions
Neuroscientist Answers Emotion Questions
Historian Answers Wild West Questions
Linguist Answers Word Origin Questions
Historian Answers Witchcraft Questions
Scammer Payback Answers Scam Questions
Urban Designer Answers More City Planning Questions
Historian Answers Pirate Questions
Cult Deprogrammer Answers Cult Questions
Historian Answers Samurai Questions
Demographics Expert Answers Population Questions
Air Crash Investigator Answers Aviation Accident Questions
Arctic Explorer Answers Polar Expedition Questions
Presidential Historian Answers Presidency Questions
Pregnancy Doctor Answers Pregnancy Questions
Paleontologist Answers Extinction Questions
Football Historian Answers Football Questions
Biomedical Scientist Answers New Pseudoscience Questions
Psychologist Answers Couples Therapy Questions
Clinical Pharmacist Answers Pharmacology Questions
Historian Answers Renaissance Questions
Dungeon Master Brennan Lee Mulligan Answers DnD Questions
Surgeon Answers Transplant Questions
Keanu Reeves Answers Motorcycle Questions With Gard Hollinger
History Professor Answers Dictator Questions
Professor Answers AI Questions
Comedian Matteo Lane Answers Stand-Up Questions
Professor Answers Supply Chain Questions
LegalEagle's Devin Stone Answers Criminal Law Questions
Doctor Answers Physical Therapy Questions
Historian Answers Cold War Questions
Cheating Expert Answers Casino Cheating Questions
Sexuality Professor Answers Dating Questions
Cybersecurity Expert Answers Hacking History Questions
Farmer Answers Farming Questions
Entomologist Answers Insect Questions
Boating Expert Answers Boat Questions
Film Historian Answers Old Hollywood Questions
Professor Answers Neurodiversity Questions
Paleontologist Answers Fossil Questions
David Guetta Answers DJ Questions
Law Professor Answers Supreme Court Questions
Astrobiologist Answers Astrobiology Questions
Political Scientist Answers China Questions
Biomedical Scientist Answers More Pseudoscience Questions
Nuclear Historian Answers Nuclear War Questions
Teacher Answers Teacher Questions
CEO Answers Startup Questions
Harvard Professor Answers Middle East Questions
Jon Batiste Answers Piano Questions
Immigration Lawyer Answers Immigration Questions
Neurosurgeon Answers Brain-Computer Interface Questions
Historian Answers Latin American History Questions
Kevin O'Leary Answers Investor Questions
Engineering Professor Answers Electric Car Questions
Language Expert Answers English Questions
Historian Answers Folklore Questions
Historian Answers Native American Questions
Economics Professor Answers Great Depression Questions
Historian Answers Revolution Questions
Max Verstappen Answers F1 Driver Questions
Mercedes CEO Answers F1 Team Principal Questions
Alex Honnold Answers Rock Climbing Questions
Army Historian Answers World War II Questions
Doctor Answers Vaccine Questions
Professor Answers Coding Questions
Historian Answers Victorian England Questions
Hideo Kojima Answers Hideo Kojima Questions
Doctor Answers Longevity Questions
Professor Answers Television History Questions
Jacques Torres Answers Chocolatier Questions
Astronomer Answers Cosmos Questions
Supply Chain Expert Answers Chinese Manufacturing Questions
Professor Answers Olympic History Questions
Paralympian Answers Paralympics Questions
Olympian Answers Figure Skating Questions
Collectibles Expert Answers Collectibles Questions
Your Rich BFF Vivian Tu Answers Personal Finance Questions
Voice Acting Legend Jim Cummings Answers Voice Acting Questions
Finance Professor Answers Investing Questions
F1 Chief Mechanic Answers F1 Car Questions
Doctor Answers Women's Health Questions
Doctor Answers Surrogacy Questions
Former Deputy National Security Advisor Answers Geopolitics Questions
Professional Birder Answers Birding Questions
Self Defense Expert Answers Self Defense Questions